Decoy Effect Is Not Exclusive of Restaurant Menus

Also named asymmetrical domination, that is a marketing strategy designed that induces us to buy more expensive products. Automakers have been using it more than ever

2024 Dodge Hornet R/T

Imagine you are craving a steak dinner and you go to a restaurant. You browse the menu, and you see that your dish costs $50. Compared to pasta and chicken options of $35, it looks quite expensive, right? Then you browse some more, and you notice that the lobster option is available for a whopping $80.

If that fictional menu made you even more interested in that steak dinner, you would have to thank the decoy effect. That marketing strategy is successful for a number of reasons and, as a result, has made its way to multiple other sectors of the industry. Here, we are going to analyze it in the automotive world.

The decoy effect is common in restaurant menus, but it has many other applications as well
The decoy effect is common in restaurant menus, but it has many other applications as well

What is the decoy effect?

The strategy of pricing one menu item (the decoy) in a way that renders another one (the target) more attractive. In the example above, the steak is not the cheapest option. However, the lobster was made so more expensive that the steak appears to be a better deal. It looks like you will get more for your money.

Wine is a typical product sold with decoy pricing
Wine is a typical product sold with decoy pricing

We can also mention the case of fast-food restaurants. When they set the soda at $3 for the small, $7 for the medium and $8 for the large, that is decoy pricing as well. Here, the medium is the decoy because it was made excessively expensive so as to induce people to buy the large one, which is the actual target.

The “asymmetric domination” name comes from how the decoy is made. In the soda case, the medium is better than the small for offering more content but is worse for being more expensive. However, it makes the large one better twice for being just a little more expensive while offering even more content.

The Volkswagen Jetta has an SEL version slotted between three base ones and the sporty GLI
The Volkswagen Jetta has an SEL version slotted between three base ones and the sporty GLI

Asymmetric domination in cars

Here, decoy pricing is common in trim levels. The Volkswagen Jetta S, for example, starts at $20,665 in the USA as of today. It also has the Sport for $21,555, the SE for $24,385, the top-tier SEL for $28,385, and the performance oriented GLI for $31,585. We can observe that strategy in several opportunities at once here.

The Jetta GLI manages to create a two-way decoy effect with the SEL
The Jetta GLI manages to create a two-way decoy effect with the SEL

Companies will always want to move customers upwards in the menu. Not only to offer a better and more beautiful product, but also to obtain higher profit margins. Adding more items to the base car is relatively easy and cheap in terms of production but allows the company to charge proportionally more from us.

The S trim exists to make the Sport look good: it costs a little more and does not have that “base” image. Parallel to that, spending roughly 40% more on the SEL does not look much next to the GLI’s $30k+ price. At the same time, the $3k difference is low enough to make the GLI look interesting for emotional drivers.

The BMW X6's coupé body offers a sporty and stylish alternative to conventional SUVs
The BMW X6’s coupé body offers a sporty and stylish alternative to conventional SUVs

What is not decoy pricing

At first, one can think that automakers do the same with car models. After all, it is easy to find a situation where one model is expensive enough to make another one more interesting. However, that is not a case of asymmetric domination for a simple reason: building a whole car model costs too much just for that.

The BMW X5 preserves the typical SUV shape with a boxier rear end
The BMW X5 preserves the typical SUV shape with a boxier rear end

In BMW’s lineup, for example, one could think that the X6 is expensive for the purpose of making the X5 a better deal. After all, the latter offers more room and is more practical. But that is a case of two products with separate purposes. What happens is that the target audience of one likes it better than the other.

The decoy effect requires adaptations in this industry because cars are a less flexible product than drinks or dishes. Making changes to them requires more effort, there is much more money involved, and target customers are more skeptical. Then again, none of that means that there is no room for innovations.

In the US, Stellantis will use decoy pricing to skew upscale customers to the Alfa Romeo Tonale...
In the US, Stellantis will use decoy pricing to skew upscale customers to the Alfa Romeo Tonale…

Latest decoy pricing example

Dodge has made the news these days because of the Hornet. While the compact SUV represents a major step in its reinvention, it can also be a risky strategy. After all, it is a badge-engineered Alfa Romeo Tonale. The US is one of the few markets where both will be available, and now we know each one’s prices there.

... while the Dodge Hornet will be made attractive for cost-oriented people
… while the Dodge Hornet will be made attractive for cost-oriented people

The Hornet has a GT trim for $31,590, an R/T for $41,590, and an R/T Plus for $46,590. The first one uses a gasoline engine while the others are hybrid. The Tonale has a Sprint trim for $ 44,590, a Ti for $46,590 and a Veloce for $49,090. All those three use the same hybrid powertrain. Can you see the decoy effect yet?

Dodge is more competitive, but it is based on low prices. Alfa Romeo has a premium image but struggles to establish itself in the region. Those prices make the Hornet attractive only at the base trim. If you want the hybrid, the Tonale brings more refinement as a whole for a price increment made small on purpose.

The Lincoln MKS had a great package in terms of luxury, space and powertrain...
The Lincoln MKS had a great package in terms of luxury, space and powertrain…

Do those biases have cons?

Of course. When it comes to junk food, inducing people to buy larger portions increases the risk of health problems. Moving on to cars, the biggest consequence is making you spend more than you wanted on a new car. And that comes with higher installments, higher interest, and more difficulty to make payments.

... but it was too little for the price premium over the Ford Taurus, which shares its platform
… but it was too little for the price premium over the Ford Taurus, which shares its platform

On the carmaker’s side, it must understand that image differentiation only goes so far. In that Alfa Romeo case, making the Tonale excessively expensive would drive even its best fans towards the Hornet (or to their competitors). The lower the price range, the less important image becomes compared to price.

If we broaden our scope, we can also think of long-term effects. Shooting brake cars, for example, never sold well for having too specific appeal. However, the fact that they cost more than a comparable station wagon only made things worse. It was a case of accidental decoy pricing that caused the opposite effect.

The Tonale will have no internal competition outside North America, so it will not need to use asymmetrical domination

Now that you know everything about asymmetrical domination, you will be able to spot it in many sectors of the market. When it comes to cars, I am sure that this knowledge is going to help you feel a little more in control of your own selection process. What other cases of decoy effect have you seen on car prices?

Sources

  • 2023 Dodge Hornet Full Pricing Is Out, and It Can Go Over $53,000Car and Driver
  • 2023 Volkswagen Jetta, 2023 Volkswagen Jetta GLIVolkswagen of America
  • Holy Tonale! New 2024 Alfa Romeo Tonale SUV Starts at $44,590Car and Driver
  • Why do we feel more strongly about one option after a third one is added?The Decision Lab
Author Profile
Editor-in-chief

Danillo Almeida has explored his passion for cars in two distinct ways. The first one is his graduation course in Mechanical Engineering, which will hopefully lead to a job position in the field. The other one is expressing his knowledge and opinions on the matter through writing. Almeida has already contributed to blogs, stores, and websites in general writing automotive content in many formats.

  • Is The Minivan Making a Comeback?
    We all know about their rise and fall. However, when everyone thought minivans were becoming history, they find a market niche with which to attract the spotlights again
  • The Ramcharger In Between
    Stellantis is releasing a plug-in hybrid pickup these days. There was the two-door SUV from the 1970s to the 1990s. But do you think that was all?
  • Moose Test Became Famous 26 Years Ago
    Under the technical name of "evasive manoeuvre test", it has been popular in the specialized press since the 1970s. However, it became famous in 1997 after a particularly serious case